Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Trending
    • Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport
    • En Garde!
    • BUWRU Still on Top
    • Hidden Histories: With The Archaeology Society
    • Beabadoobee Concert Review: Welcome to Beatopia
    • Taylor Swift: Midnights Review – The Stories of 13 Sleepless Nights
    • Claire Concert Review: Claire Cottrill in Concert!
    • Is There Hope For Percy Jackson?
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Flickr
    Seren
    • News & Politics
      1. Local News
      2. UK News
      3. Uni News
      4. World News
      5. Politics
      6. Comment
      7. Business
      Featured

      SABB Election: The Full Result Breakdown

      By Emily ReadMarch 20, 20210
      Recent

      Redevelopment plans and the culture of Bangor

      October 28, 2022

      Immediate closure of Menai Bridge following reports of structural integrity issues

      October 28, 2022

      Racial abuse victim calls for harsher sentencing following nightclub assault

      October 28, 2022
    • Arts & Culture
      1. Books
      2. Games
      3. Film
      4. Music
      5. TV
      6. Creative Corner
      Featured

      Bangor alumni podcast earns Hollywood cameo & BBC features

      By Amelia SmithMarch 7, 20210
      Recent

      Beabadoobee Concert Review: Welcome to Beatopia

      October 29, 2022

      Taylor Swift: Midnights Review – The Stories of 13 Sleepless Nights

      October 29, 2022

      Claire Concert Review: Claire Cottrill in Concert!

      October 29, 2022
    • Lifestyle
      1. Fashion
      2. Food and Drink
      3. Social
      4. Health and Beauty
      5. Travel
      Featured

      Country Highlight: The Netherlands

      By Emily ShoultsMay 6, 20220
      Recent

      Gilmore Garms

      October 28, 2022

      Fleeces and Funk

      October 28, 2022

      Cheerleading: Getting your kit together

      October 28, 2022
    • Discovery
      1. Science
      2. Environment
      3. History
      4. International
      Featured

      Brewing up a Storm: The History of Guinness

      By Emily ReadMarch 20, 20210
      Recent

      North Wales Ramblings

      October 28, 2022

      Hamza Yassin: The Hard Work That Is Making Luck Happen

      October 28, 2022

      Student’s Union Hosts Repair Cafe for Sustainability Awareness Week

      October 28, 2022
    • Sport
      1. Varsity 2019
      2. Varsity 2018
      3. Varsity 2017
      4. Varsity 2016
      5. Varsity 2015
      6. Varsity 2014
      7. Varsity 2013
        • Varsity 2013 Results
        • Varsity 2013 – In tweets
      Featured

      Bangor Muddogs’ American Football: a young woman finding her place

      By Jade HillMarch 23, 20210
      Recent

      Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport

      October 29, 2022

      En Garde!

      October 29, 2022

      BUWRU Still on Top

      October 29, 2022
    • Students’ Union
      1. Union News
      2. Societies
      3. Volunteering
      4. Clubs
      Featured

      INTERVIEW: Be Period Positive

      By Caroline CartmillMarch 17, 20210
      Recent

      Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport

      October 29, 2022

      En Garde!

      October 29, 2022

      BUWRU Still on Top

      October 29, 2022
    • Issues
      • Current Issue
      • This year’s issues
      • Last year’s issues
      • Seren Archive
      • Seren Teams
    Seren
    Home»Arts & Culture»Books»Amazon and the Reviewer: Censorship in the Marketplace?
    Books

    Amazon and the Reviewer: Censorship in the Marketplace?

    Jordan GlendenningBy Jordan GlendenningJuly 14, 2015No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    At the start of July, writer Imy Santiago wrote a blog entry on her website which caused a small media frenzy.

    The post, entitled Amazon… A virtual marketplace, or Big Brother?, talked about how she had written a review for a fellow writer on Amazon’s platform and was surprised and a little peeved to find she was unable to post the review. She then received an explanatory e-mail from the company.

    You can read the full post on her site here.

    For those who don’t know, Amazon has a set of rules about posting reviews on their marketplace. As their page here states, those rules rejecting specific reviews include:

    • Reviews not about the product — i.e. seller and shipping experience or product availability and feedback.
    • Reviews which contain inappropriate or offensive content — i.e. profanity, phone numbers, other people’s material, hate speech, or promotion of illegal conduct.
    • Promotional content — i.e. authors, artists, developers writing for their own products, “[for]the same reason, family members or close friends… may not write Customer Reviews for those particular items” and paid reviews, which are reviews posted in return for compensation of any kind.

    All of this makes sense for a company who want to promote objective reviews on products so that a customer has as unbiased a representation of a potential purchase as possible.

    The problem as Imy Santiago described it was that Amazon has overstepped the mark and strayed into territory they have no business being in.

    According to the reply Amazon gave Santiago, the way they determine whether a reviewer has a personal relationship with an author is ‘proprietary’ and cannot be given away.

    Speculation has it that their method of detection is an algorithm which automatically trawls the social media sites, such as Twitter, Facebook, and perhaps Amazon-owned Goodreads, to figure out if there is a connection between reader and writer.

    In Santiago’s case, she is an independent author who has rubbed elbows with a peer in a relatively small online community. It seems extreme to jump to refusing to publish reviews in cases such as this.

    Amazon’s response on the matter does not help to promote the kind of situation in which this could just die down and let the marketplace free reign in its content policy. From canned responses to a flat out refusal to communicate further on the issue, they are being rather tight-lipped.

    A US author, Jas Ward, started a petition on Change.org calling for Amazon to reverse the decision. As of Monday evening, it had 12,740 signatures.

    Nearly 13,000 people now have eyes on an issue many are calling censorship – a topic which is always a hotbed in literary circles.

    From Fahrenheit 451 to Nineteen Eight-Four, this issue is always in the back of readers’ minds. For the company to get a computer to decide whether or not two people, who may have never met in person, are close friends and then actively stop them from posting reviews for each other does seem like a rather strange solution to the problem. Doing this, for want of a better term, snooping on a customer without their consent seems a little more than strange.

    However, speaking on the side of Amazon for a moment, there’s every chance that such an algorithm would only ever get better if they tested it in live situations. Amazon does not want false reviews which detract from a neutral stance on the products. They are doing a Good Thing (TM) by trying to keep reviews honest.

    But are they going about it the wrong way?

    For 13,000 people, it seems like they are.

    One thing is certain, this is only the start. It has been two weeks since Santiago’s blog post, and news outlets like the Guardian have picked up on it. If they were looking for a quiet resolution to a single isolated case, they’re in for a surprise.

    Amazon will need to respond to this, and we’ll be here with ears perked for when they do.

    algorithms Amazon Big Brother Censorship Indie authors reviews
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Jordan Glendenning

    Books Editor 2015/16

    Related Posts

    Hocus Pocus 2

    October 28, 2022

    The Lost King

    October 28, 2022

    Hamza Yassin: The Hard Work That Is Making Luck Happen

    October 28, 2022

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    MORE INFORMATION
    • ABOUT
    • ADVERTISE
    • CONTACT US
    • GET INVOLVED
    • MEMBERS
    Links
    • Bangor University Bangor University
    • Google+ Google+
    • Undeb Bangor Undeb Bangor
    About

    Seren is Bangor University Students’ Union’s English Language Newspaper

    We have editorial independence from both Bangor University and Bangor Students’ Union. Seren is written by students for students and we’d love you to get involved!

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.