Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Trending
    • Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport
    • En Garde!
    • BUWRU Still on Top
    • Hidden Histories: With The Archaeology Society
    • Beabadoobee Concert Review: Welcome to Beatopia
    • Taylor Swift: Midnights Review – The Stories of 13 Sleepless Nights
    • Claire Concert Review: Claire Cottrill in Concert!
    • Is There Hope For Percy Jackson?
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Flickr
    Seren
    • News & Politics
      1. Local News
      2. UK News
      3. Uni News
      4. World News
      5. Politics
      6. Comment
      7. Business
      Featured

      SABB Election: The Full Result Breakdown

      By Emily ReadMarch 20, 20210
      Recent

      Redevelopment plans and the culture of Bangor

      October 28, 2022

      Immediate closure of Menai Bridge following reports of structural integrity issues

      October 28, 2022

      Racial abuse victim calls for harsher sentencing following nightclub assault

      October 28, 2022
    • Arts & Culture
      1. Books
      2. Games
      3. Film
      4. Music
      5. TV
      6. Creative Corner
      Featured

      Bangor alumni podcast earns Hollywood cameo & BBC features

      By Amelia SmithMarch 7, 20210
      Recent

      Beabadoobee Concert Review: Welcome to Beatopia

      October 29, 2022

      Taylor Swift: Midnights Review – The Stories of 13 Sleepless Nights

      October 29, 2022

      Claire Concert Review: Claire Cottrill in Concert!

      October 29, 2022
    • Lifestyle
      1. Fashion
      2. Food and Drink
      3. Social
      4. Health and Beauty
      5. Travel
      Featured

      Country Highlight: The Netherlands

      By Emily ShoultsMay 6, 20220
      Recent

      Gilmore Garms

      October 28, 2022

      Fleeces and Funk

      October 28, 2022

      Cheerleading: Getting your kit together

      October 28, 2022
    • Discovery
      1. Science
      2. Environment
      3. History
      4. International
      Featured

      Brewing up a Storm: The History of Guinness

      By Emily ReadMarch 20, 20210
      Recent

      North Wales Ramblings

      October 28, 2022

      Hamza Yassin: The Hard Work That Is Making Luck Happen

      October 28, 2022

      Student’s Union Hosts Repair Cafe for Sustainability Awareness Week

      October 28, 2022
    • Sport
      1. Varsity 2019
      2. Varsity 2018
      3. Varsity 2017
      4. Varsity 2016
      5. Varsity 2015
      6. Varsity 2014
      7. Varsity 2013
        • Varsity 2013 Results
        • Varsity 2013 – In tweets
      Featured

      Bangor Muddogs’ American Football: a young woman finding her place

      By Jade HillMarch 23, 20210
      Recent

      Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport

      October 29, 2022

      En Garde!

      October 29, 2022

      BUWRU Still on Top

      October 29, 2022
    • Students’ Union
      1. Union News
      2. Societies
      3. Volunteering
      4. Clubs
      Featured

      INTERVIEW: Be Period Positive

      By Caroline CartmillMarch 17, 20210
      Recent

      Interview: Lewis Thompson, VP Sport

      October 29, 2022

      En Garde!

      October 29, 2022

      BUWRU Still on Top

      October 29, 2022
    • Issues
      • Current Issue
      • This year’s issues
      • Last year’s issues
      • Seren Archive
      • Seren Teams
    Seren
    Home»Arts & Culture»Books»Should We Separate Books & Their Adaptations?
    Books

    Should We Separate Books & Their Adaptations?

    Holly PeckittBy Holly PeckittApril 24, 2021No Comments3 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Photo by Shayna Douglas

    As ever, we are being inundated with more literary adaptations of popular texts than ever before. While the pandemic has hit productions and shooting hard, the beauty of a staggered release date has never been so appreciated, especially when fans of a book flock together to see its TV or film adaptation.  In many of the Netflix binges that have ensued over recent months, we’ve all found ourselves addicted to a particular show or another re-watch of that new film, but at what point do we lose our sense of magic? Critics rave and criticise and we want to lose ourselves in something new,to delve into a box set or a 90-minute film. But at what point does the literary adaptation lose its magic touch? 

    This semester there have been two series that I’ve binged on Netflix: Bridgerton and Firefly Lane, both of which are adaptations from successful books, both of which are very different from their origins of birth, but can we call these original texts their predecessors if they’re so different? 

    Season 1 of Bridgerton has developed from Julia Quinn’s novel The Duke and I, the first in a series of seven books. We all know another seven-book series that has become hugely successful, but in that case many argued the books were better than the films. With Bridgerton, I’d like to argue the opposite. Lately Quinn’s series has been heavily criticised for issues surrounding ethnicity and sexual consent, and in a world where fair, equal and just representation of minorities and of victims’ voices is paramount, Bridgerton uses The Duke and I as merely a skeleton for the plot, onto which a diverse range of voices are celebrated.

    Firefly Lane, whilst an easier ride in the book (according to Oprah.com), is a gripping adaptation. No it’s not amazing, but it’s a sweet exploration of the friendships that get us through the toughest of times and what we do when they supposedly run their course. Kate and Tully’s friendship isn’t plain-sailing but strips it back from the wealth they’ve somehow acquired and it’s believable, touching and humble, demonstrating how friendships evolve, regenerate and face struggles in the race to stay alive. There are marriages on the brink, decisions between selfish and selfless and plenty of humour tinged with chilling moments of sadness, but it’s real. After finishing Season 1, I had to know how the story continues. My only source? The source text, Firefly Lane by Kristin Hannah, which personally I find reads as a stagnant, plain story from which the very best parts have been taken and conjured into life by Netflix’s adaptation. From reading the plot and what happens next, this is one of the few occasions where I’d prefer to stick with the series over the book! Really Hannah’s book is a springboard for something greater, something that challenges social conventions of its time period (set in 2003) and makes Hannah’s story the very best it can be, bringing it into 2021 with progressive attitudes and a subtle commentary on society’s treatment of gender and sexuality. 

    What do you think? These are only two snapshots on literary adaptations in 2021, but should this be the norm? Should we separate the text and it’s adaptation?

    Bridgerton Firefly Lane
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Holly Peckitt

    Books Editor | 20-21 Travel Editor | 19-20

    Related Posts

    Jane Austen in Lockdown: How her six novels are more relevant than ever

    July 7, 2021

    Shakespeariana: 5 Accessible Retellings

    May 1, 2021

    Love & Loyalty: The Best Mothers in Literature

    April 17, 2021

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    MORE INFORMATION
    • ABOUT
    • ADVERTISE
    • CONTACT US
    • GET INVOLVED
    • MEMBERS
    Links
    • Bangor University Bangor University
    • Google+ Google+
    • Undeb Bangor Undeb Bangor
    About

    Seren is Bangor University Students’ Union’s English Language Newspaper

    We have editorial independence from both Bangor University and Bangor Students’ Union. Seren is written by students for students and we’d love you to get involved!

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.